A spokesperson for the National Council of Canadian Muslims (NCCM) expressed that there is "a real opportunity here" following a series of anti-Muslim videos posted by Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander on social media. These videos were shared shortly after the U.S. midterm elections and were taken down two days later.
Steven Zhou, the NCCM’s media and communications lead, indicated that while the posts were disheartening and "very disconcerting," the council was optimistic that the situation could foster positive change. He emphasized that the community desires a strengthened relationship with Santander and, importantly, an apology from him.
The Blue Jays responded to the incident, stating, "Baseball is for everyone," and reaffirmed their commitment to creating an inclusive environment for all fans at their ballpark. The organization clarified that individual comments do not reflect their values and beliefs.
The posted videos featured a Christian preacher proclaiming, "There is no such thing as kind Muslims," while another suggested that Sharia law would be implemented in the U.S. after Abdul El-Sayed was elected to the Senate in Michigan. El-Sayed, the son of Egyptian immigrants, is poised to become the first Muslim American U.S. senator and has faced Islamophobic rhetoric during his campaign.
Anthony Santander, 32, who endured a series of injuries that limited his play last season, signed a five-year, $92.5 million contract with the Blue Jays in January 2025. Zhou pointed out that athletes and sports teams should symbolize unity, particularly in a diverse city like Toronto, where fans from various backgrounds gather to watch games. He expressed disappointment that Santander's sentiments could reinforce negative stereotypes about Muslims.
Muslim Community Upset Following Social Media Posts
Emad Ahmed, a 26-year-old influencer from Oakville, voiced his shock at Santander's posts, noting they were particularly upsetting as a devoted Blue Jays fan and a member of the Muslim community. He highlighted that such behavior from athletes could deter inclusivity in sports.
Abdul Murad, commissioner of the One Ummah Softball league, remarked that he was taken aback to see a professional athlete sharing Islamophobic sentiments, especially considering the overall passion he has for the Blue Jays. Murad added that many Muslim fans were dissatisfied with the lack of a robust response from the team.
Morgan McLellan, a managing partner at a crisis communications advisory firm named Sovereign, criticized the Blue Jays' reaction as inadequate. He suggested that failing to address the issue seriously could alienate many fans, particularly within the Muslim community, who deserve a comprehensive response and a clear action plan from the organization.
Santander's Future in Toronto Uncertain
This controversy is not the first the Blue Jays have faced regarding players' social media activity. Earlier in May 2023, reliever Anthony Bass drew backlash after posting support for boycotts against companies that supported the LGBTQ+ community. Although Bass later apologized and met with representatives from Pride Toronto, he maintained his personal beliefs and was subsequently designated for assignment before the team's Pride weekend, ultimately leading to his release.
The potential consequences for Santander remain unclear, with experts suggesting possible outcomes such as a fine, a short suspension, or sensitivity training. Sports lawyer Emir Crowne noted that a genuine apology from Santander could be beneficial in any disciplinary discussions.
Meanwhile, Zhou from NCCM expressed hope that the organization would engage with both the player and the Blue Jays' ownership. He reiterated that the NCCM is open to discussions aimed at fostering a constructive relationship moving forward.
