21.07.2025

Father's Inconsistent Story in Daughter's Death Case

The death of a 9-year-old girl whose father initially reported she was missing and possibly abducted is being investigated amid “inconsistencies” in his account, police said Sunday after the girl’s body was found in New York state

The investigation surrounding the tragic death of 9-year-old Melina Frattolin is intensifying as authorities reveal inconsistencies in the account provided by her father, Luciano Frattolin. Initially reported as missing and potentially abducted, Melina's body was discovered on Sunday in New York state, specifically in the Ticonderoga area, approximately 30 miles east of Lake George, where she was last seen. The discovery came during a search operation involving K9 teams and aviation units, as authorities sought to locate the young girl.

Melina Frattolin and her father, Luciano, are residents of Canada, and the latter reported her disappearance late Saturday evening near Lake George in the northeastern part of New York. Following the developments, the New York State Police have stated that they have identified multiple inconsistencies in Luciano Frattolin's timeline and narrative regarding the events surrounding Melina's disappearance.

As the investigation unfolds, law enforcement officials have clarified that there is currently no evidence to suggest that an abduction took place. Additionally, they assured the public that there is no ongoing threat, although they have not provided detailed statements regarding the father's original claims or the circumstances that led to the death of the young girl.

In a significant detail, the police confirmed that a press conference is scheduled for Monday, likely to provide further updates and insights into the investigation. Meanwhile, the whereabouts of Luciano Frattolin remain unclear as of late Sunday, and he has not responded to requests for comment that were sent through various social media platforms, including LinkedIn, Instagram, and his company website.

Luciano Frattolin has portrayed himself as a dedicated and loving father on his social media profiles. His Instagram account reflects this sentiment, where he describes Melina as "the light of his life." Furthermore, a post on the website of a coffee company he allegedly founded highlights Melina's significance, stating that she is “the inspiration for… well, everything,” showcasing the deep bond he professes to have with his daughter.

The shocking turn of events has raised questions and concerns within the community, particularly given the grave nature of the situation involving a child. As authorities continue to investigate, the focus remains not only on the circumstances leading to Melina’s death but also on the accuracy of the accounts provided by her father. The investigation represents a critical effort by law enforcement to uncover the truth behind this tragic incident.