4.11.2025

Court Allows Caretaker Council in Mohawk Community

MONTREAL — The Federal Court has decided that five outgoing chiefs of a Montreal-area Mohawk community can form a caretaker council more than two months after an election was abruptly cancelled

MONTREAL — In a significant ruling, the Federal Court has allowed five outgoing chiefs of the Mohawk Council of Kanesatake, located in the Montreal area, to form a caretaker council. This decision comes more than two months after an election scheduled for August 2, 2025, was abruptly cancelled by the chief electoral officer just one day prior to the voting date.

The court's ruling on Thursday grants the five chiefs a limited mandate. Their responsibilities will focus on delivering essential services to the community members and handling necessary administrative tasks. Establishing a caretaker council is viewed as a crucial measure to prevent a governance vacuum in Kanesatake, which has been grappling with significant political uncertainty.

Since the cancellation of the election, the chiefs have faced considerable challenges, including losing access to crucial band facilities and their official council email accounts. The court ruling highlighted that the ongoing uncertainty and confusion within the community could lead to "irreparable harm." This situation underscores the tension and division present within Kanesatake, as some community members, including the former grand chief, have accused the five incumbent chiefs of attempting to cling to power.

In the wake of these challenges, the incumbent chiefs have sought a judicial determination regarding the timelines and procedures for holding a new election. However, the court has scheduled a full hearing on this matter for 2026, indicating that the resolution to this political controversy may take significant time to emerge.

The implications of the court's decision are wide-ranging, as it reflects not only the internal struggles of the Mohawk Council of Kanesatake but also highlights the complexities of governance in indigenous communities facing disputes over leadership and representation. As the interim caretakers step in to stabilize governance, the coming months will be pivotal for shaping the future of the community.