15.06.2025

"American Catholics Embrace First U.S.-Born Pope"

WASHINGTON (AP) — Just over a month after Pope Leo XIV became the first U

WASHINGTON (AP) – Just over a month after Pope Leo XIV became the first U.S.-born pontiff in the history of the Catholic Church, a new poll indicates that American Catholics are feeling generally positive about their new religious leader.

According to a recent survey conducted by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, approximately two-thirds of American Catholics express a “very” or “somewhat” favorable view of Pope Leo. In contrast, about 30% of respondents indicated that they do not know enough to form an opinion, while fewer than 10% view him unfavorably.

Among the broader U.S. adult population, many have yet to solidify their opinions about Pope Leo. However, those who do express a view tend to have overwhelmingly positive feelings. The survey highlights that 44% of U.S. adults hold a “somewhat” or “very” favorable view of Pope Leo XIV. A similar proportion of respondents reported not knowing enough to form an opinion, while roughly 10% view him unfavorably.

Pope Leo, aiming for unity within a polarized church, seems to inspire optimism among Americans with diverse perspectives about the future of the church. Terry Barber, a 50-year-old Catholic from Sacramento, California, voiced hope that Leo will lead the church towards a more progressive stance that embraces inclusivity.

“I’m optimistic. Certainly, the first pope from the United States is significant,” said Barber, who identifies as a Democrat. He added that while he assumes Leo shares some views with his predecessor, there are likely original ideas from Leo that he looks forward to seeing.

The appeal of Pope Leo appears to be bipartisan. Around half of Democrats hold a favorable opinion of the new pope, while approximately 40% of Republicans and independents share similar sentiments. Interestingly, Republicans are more likely than Democrats to withhold judgment, with about half stating they don’t know enough to form an opinion. However, the number of unfavorable views remains consistent across both parties, at roughly 10% each.

Victoria Becude, a 38-year-old Republican Catholic from Florida, expressed excitement over having the first U.S.-born pope, emphasizing her hope that he can guide the nation toward a stronger adherence to Catholic doctrine.

“I’m rooting for him,” Becude stated. “I hope that America can get back to faith, and I hope he can do that.”

The survey suggested that identifying as a political liberal or conservative does not translate directly to feelings towards Pope Leo among Catholics. Responses from the poll show that Catholics across the ideological spectrum have expressed hope that Leo will help heal the divisions that arose during Pope Francis’ tenure.

Recently, Pope Leo criticized the rise of nationalist movements worldwide and emphasized reconciliation and dialogue, aligning with his commitment to make the Catholic Church a symbol of peace.

Prior to his elevation to the papacy, Cardinal Robert Prevost oversaw significant reforms under Pope Francis, including initiatives involving female representation in church governance. However, Leo has also firmly stated that women cannot be ordained as priests. Donald Hallstone, a 72-year-old Catholic from Oregon, expressed a desire to see more women in significant church roles, particularly amidst a shortage of clergy.

Responses to Pope Leo are still forming, especially after his recent appointments and the direction of his clerical focus becomes clearer. A notable portion of Americans, particularly from non-Catholic backgrounds, remain undecided about their views on the pope. Around half of born-again Protestants, mainline Protestants, and individuals without religious affiliation do not hold a definite opinion about him yet.

Age demographics also play a role in the reception of Pope Leo. Older Americans, more likely to identify as Catholics, tend to favor him more than younger Americans. Approximately half of those aged 60 and older view Pope Leo positively, compared to around 40% of adults under 30.

Mercedes Drink, 31, from the pope's hometown of Chicago, is hopeful that his leadership will usher in changes that women, in particular, will appreciate. She identifies as part of the “religious nones” and believes that Leo brings an opportunity for modernizing the church.

“It’s cool; I like him because he brings something different,” Drink commented. “As a young woman, I hope he can bring change and increase diversity.”